3 Comments
User's avatar
Justin Gielski's avatar

Great work. Iโ€™m glad you addressed the invocation of โ€œemergent propertiesโ€ as well.

๐•ฎ๐–”๐–š๐–—๐–†๐–Œ๐–Š๐–”๐–š๐–˜ ๐•ฎ๐–๐–—๐–Ž๐–˜'s avatar

For some reason, modern intellectual atheists are quite fond of emergent properties, and I have no idea why. It causes more problems for them and solves none.

Justin Gielski's avatar

I agree! Iโ€™ve seen a lot of โ€œbrute factโ€ escapes of late too, primarily in response to the moral and cosmological arguments.

Anything that can be explained by God, but not by naturalism, is just a โ€œBrute Factโ€ now.

No evidence, no reasoning, just a way to escape where logical reasoning ends.

As an aside, I wonder how many of those who invoke emergent properties also advocate for AI advancement while believing AI cannot become sentient. If consciousness can truly emerge from sufficiently complex physical systems, then it would seem AI is potentially far more dangerous than we are led to believe, and we may be on a path toward Terminator. I point this out because I suspect there may be some inconsistent reasoning at play among naturalists.